Written by Kamya Jain, The author is a law student pursuing BBA.LLB from Jindal Global Law School.
In the complex arena of financial markets, insider trading and market manipulation persist as prominent threats, eroding the foundational fairness of the marketplace. Standing firm against these daunting challenges is the Securities and Exchange Board of India (hereinafter “SEBI”), an unwavering guardian deploying strategic countermeasures to deter these unscrupulous practices. The efforts of SEBI span from strong legislative measures to the implementation of cutting-edge technical solutions and strict enforcement systems. This blog will provide insight on SEBI's multidimensional strategy by discussing its efforts to strengthen itself, inform investors, and benefit from international partnerships. Each of these factors contributes to SEBI's overarching goal of maintaining credibility and transparency in the market and by delving into the initiatives taken by SEBI to safeguard the Indian securities one will have an illuminating understanding of their dedicated efforts.
Insider Trading: Mitigating the Risk
Insider trading involves the act of buying or selling a publicly listed company's stocks or other securities based on material information about the company that is not publicly available. The root causes of insider trading in India are multifaceted. The intertwining of corporate governance and family connections has long been a contributing factor, since it facilitates the exchange of confidential information amongst individuals with similar backgrounds. In addition, technical developments and the pace at which the stock market is evolving have sometimes surpassed the regulatory processes, leaving room for error. Another reason is that stakeholders have not been adequately informed about insider trading regulations. Additionally, inefficiencies in monitoring and enforcement mechanisms, along with challenges in evidence collection, have sometimes hindered effective prosecution. Insider trading is an illicit practice that erodes the confidence of investors and disrupts market integrity. In response to mitigating these risks, SEBI established the SEBI (Prohibition of Insider Trading) Regulations, 2015, superseding the older regulations from 1992. The 2015 regulations provide a more encompassing definition of an “insider” to include individuals connected via a contractual, fiduciary, or employment relationship that provides access to Unpublished Price Sensitive Information (hereinafter “UPSI”). The definition of "connected persons" has been expanded to incorporate those who may not seemingly be in an official position in a company but are consistently interacting with the company and its officers. Moreover, SEBI has mandated the creation of a Code of Conduct for overseeing, monitoring, and reporting trading by insiders. The expansive rules and broader definitions have amplified the enforcement scope, restricting opportunities for unlawful benefits from insider trading.
Deterring Market Manipulation: A Continuous Endeavour
Market manipulation signifies the illegal practice of artificially inflating or deflating the price of a security, achieved by disseminating false or misleading information about the company. To combat this, SEBI has instituted the SEBI (Prohibition of Fraudulent and Unfair Trade Practices relating to Securities Market) Regulations, 2003. These regulations provide a detailed description of actions constituting market manipulation, which includes the use of manipulative and deceptive devices, creation of false or misleading appearances of trading, and involvement in fraudulent or unfair trade practices. SEBI also implemented an Integrated Surveillance System (hereinafter “ISS”), a tool that oversees unusual market activities and generates alerts for subsequent investigation. This unified system enables SEBI to track irregularities across exchanges and take immediate corrective actions.
Implementation: SEBI's Defending Mechanism Against Malpractice
Effective implementation of these regulations is key to their success. SEBI has adopted numerous enforcement mechanisms, ranging from administrative actions, financial penalties to criminal prosecution. A noteworthy case is the Infosys insider trading case where SEBI levied a total fine of INR 9.5 million on an Infosys employee and seven other individuals for violating insider trading norms. Instances like these underscore SEBI's dedication to the rigorous execution of its regulations. Additionally, SEBI fosters a culture of self-regulation and cooperation. It encourages companies to incorporate internal safeguards to mitigate insider trading and market manipulation, including instituting "trading windows" and establishing guidelines for the handling of UPSI.
Augmenting Transparency: Forging Ahead
Transparency is of utmost importance to a stable securities market. In 2020, SEBI brought forward an amendment to the Insider Trading Regulations, necessitating companies to maintain a register of all individuals and entities privy to UPSI. This initiative bolsters the traceability of information flow and enforces accountability. Moreover, to ascertain a fair and informed marketplace, SEBI directs listed companies to quickly disclose UPSI to the stock exchanges. This mandate, as per the SEBI (Listing Obligations and Disclosure Requirements) Regulations, 2015, guarantees uniform access to critical corporate data for all participants in the market.
Progress in Technology: Instruments for Improved Oversight
The evolution of technology has revolutionized financial markets and equipped regulators with advanced surveillance tools. SEBI's pioneering system, the Advanced Warning and Risk Assessment System (AWRAS), launched in 2015, employs data analytics to spot potential cases of market manipulation and insider trading. It considers a multitude of factors such as trading volume, pricing, circuit filters, and the ratio of orders to trades to generate alerts for unusual market activities. These alerts are then subjected to further examination for potential violations. SEBI has also integrated artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning (ML) methods for superior anomaly detection. These technologies pave the way for more precise market movement predictions, the discernment of intricate trading patterns, and the identification of manipulation strategies such as layering and spoofing. Moreover, with the surge in social media and digital communication platforms, SEBI has equipped itself to trace attempts of market manipulation through these channels. The authority closely observes online discussions, hearsay, and news that could potentially influence market conduct, hence thwarting manipulation arising from false or misleading data.
Bolstering the Regulatory Ecosystem: Alliances and Partnerships
Acknowledging the cross-border nature of financial crimes, SEBI has formed cooperative agreements with several international regulators, including the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the UK Financial Conduct Authority (FCA). These partnerships enable SEBI to exchange crucial enforcement-related information, thus empowering it to take potent action against cross-border violations. SEBI also actively engages in global forums like the International Organization of Securities Commissions (IOSCO), facilitating the alignment of its rules and practices with international standards.
Investor Education: A Crucial Component of Market Safeguarding
Alongside stringent rule enforcement and the deployment of sophisticated surveillance systems, SEBI places significant importance on investor education. It has initiated several programs to instruct investors about their rights and duties, the various forms of financial fraud, and strategies for their protection. The “SEBI SCORES” (SEBI Complaints Redress System) allows investors to file their complaints online, thereby making the grievance redressal process more efficient.
Pioneering with Technology: SEBI's Digitization Strategy
The advent of digital technology has equipped SEBI with substantial capabilities in its crusade against illegitimate market activities. This is shown by the implementation of electronic Initial Public Offerings (hereinafter “e-IPOs”), which have served to lessen the time required for the listing process, consequently shrinking the opportunity for fraudulent practices. In 2019, SEBI charted out a 'regulatory sandbox' structure to stimulate FinTech innovation within the securities market. This sandbox furnishes a controlled and safe environment for FinTech firms to test ground-breaking solutions that can bolster SEBI's objective of preventing market malpractices. This action echoes SEBI's forward-thinking approach. By fostering a platform for FinTech innovation, SEBI is not only preparing for the future of the market but also potentially furnishing itself with even more sophisticated tools to identify and avert financial fraud.
Tightening Broker Regulations
In its continued efforts, SEBI has also rolled out stricter rules for brokers to avert unauthorized trading. Brokers are now obligated to provide clients with a way to acknowledge receipt of any modifications to their order instructions, and to preserve a record of all instructions received from clients for a minimum duration of three years.
Amplifying Cybersecurity Measures
Given the escalating reliance on digital platforms, SEBI has highlighted the importance of augmenting cybersecurity infrastructure to shield market integrity. Guidelines from SEBI necessitate all entities under its jurisdiction to adopt sturdy and secure cybersecurity frameworks. These frameworks are designed to protect systems from unauthorized access, detect and report cyber-attacks promptly, and recover from such attacks swiftly. By advocating for cybersecurity, SEBI is safeguarding its surveillance systems from compromise and assuring investors of the security of the digital platforms they utilize for trading.
International Approaches to Insider Trading: Lessons and Strategies for SEBI
Market fairness and transparency are guaranteed by strict insider trading restrictions in a number of nations. Under the Securities Exchange Act of 1935, which was created to prevent insider trading in the United States, the Securities Exchange Commission goes after anybody who trades shares based on material, non-public knowledge. SEBI should think about expanding its definition of "insiders" to include anybody who trades stocks based on substantial, non-public knowledge, regardless of their official status with the firm. Another example will be the UK's Financial Conduct Authority, which works to prevent insider trading by enforcing the Market Abuse Regulation. Through its two-pronged approach, including both civil and criminal consequences, this rule has widened the definition of insider trading and expanded its reach to new markets and platforms. In this case, SEBI may use a dual system of civil and criminal punishments to improve the efficiency of the enforcement procedure. The SEBI may strengthen its framework by collaborating with foreign securities authorities to exchange insights and best practises and by making use of artificial intelligence (AI) and data analytics technologies to better detect suspicious trading trends.
Conclusion
SEBI's relentless strides in curbing market malpractices like insider trading and market manipulation stand testament to its commitment towards a transparent and trustworthy securities market in India. These developments include the augmentation of laws, adoption of advanced surveillance tools, and promotion of investor education. The introduction of comprehensive regulations like the SEBI (Prohibition of Insider Trading) Regulations, 2015, and the SEBI (Prohibition of Fraudulent and Unfair Trade Practices relating to Securities Market) Regulations, 2003, have strengthened the legal infrastructure against these illicit activities. Further, leveraging technology and innovation has allowed SEBI to stay ahead of the curve. Whether it's the deployment of the Advanced Warning and Risk Assessment System (AWRAS) or the embracement of digital platforms and AI, SEBI's approach reflects a strong commitment towards market integrity.
Moreover, recognizing the importance of collaboration in tackling cross-border violations, SEBI's partnerships with international regulatory bodies enhance its effectiveness in maintaining a fair market environment. However, in this fast-evolving financial landscape, maintaining market integrity is a continual process. As technology advances and newer forms of trading emerge, SEBI must continue to adapt its regulations, strengthen its surveillance mechanisms, and deepen its investor education initiatives. With such persistent efforts, SEBI ensures that the Indian securities market remains a paragon of fairness and transparency, fostering investor trust and facilitating the healthy growth of the Indian economy. SEBI's dedicated pursuit of these goals continues to inspire confidence in both domestic and international investors, proving instrumental in shaping a resilient financial market infrastructure in India.
Comments